Understanding What is Patentability Search

A patentability search is a systematic investigation conducted before filing a patent application to discover any existing prior art that could affect your invention's eligibility for patent protection. This critical pre-filing evaluation examines both patented and non-patented documents worldwide to assess whether your invention truly represents something new and non-obvious in its field.

The process involves searching through millions of patent documents, scientific publications, technical journals, and online resources to identify any references that display the same or similar features as your contemplated invention. Understanding what is patentability search and its importance can save inventors thousands of dollars and countless hours by revealing potential obstacles before investing in the patent application process.

The Core Purpose: Why Conduct a Patentability Search?

The fundamental question many inventors ask is: what is patentability search designed to achieve? The primary objectives include:

Novelty Assessment

A patentability search determines whether your invention has been previously disclosed to the public in any form. This includes examining patent databases, scientific literature, product catalogs, websites, and any other publicly available information that might constitute prior art.

Non-Obviousness Evaluation

Beyond novelty, the search helps establish whether your invention represents a non-obvious advancement over existing technologies. This is crucial because patent offices reject applications for inventions that merely combine known elements in predictable ways.

Cost and Resource Optimization

Conducting a patentability search before filing saves substantial costs associated with patent drafting, filing fees, and prosecution expenses. If the search reveals similar existing inventions, you can either abandon the project, modify your invention to distinguish it from prior art, or redirect resources to more promising innovations.

Key Components of an Effective Patentability Search

Search Sources and Databases

When examining what is patentability search methodology, comprehensive coverage across multiple information sources is essential:

Patent Databases:

• United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)
• European Patent Office (EPO) and Espacenet
• World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) databases
• Orbit and Derwent Innovation (covering 100+ jurisdictions)
• Google Patents for broad accessibility
• Regional patent offices across Asia, South America, and other territories

Non-Patent Literature:

• Scientific journals (ScienceDirect, Pubmed)
• Academic publications and university research
• Industry reports and technical standards
• Conference proceedings and presentations
• Product catalogs and marketing materials
• Online technical forums and documentation

Strategic Search Methodologies

Understanding what is patentability search requires knowing the various search strategies employed:

• Keyword-Based Searching: This involves identifying relevant technical terms, synonyms, and phrases that describe your invention's features, functions, and applications. The keyword approach captures documents that might not be properly classified but contain relevant technical disclosures.
• Classification-Based Searching: Patent classification systems like the Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC), International Patent Classification (IPC), and United States Classification (USC) organize patents by technology areas. This systematic approach ensures comprehensive coverage within specific technical domains.
• Assignee and Inventor Searches: Identifying key players in your technology space helps locate relevant prior art from competitors, research institutions, and prolific inventors working in similar areas.
• Citation and Spider Searching: Examining the references cited by relevant patents and the patents that cite them creates a web of related prior art that might not surface through other search methods.

The Three-Phase Patentability Search Process

Phase 1: Technology Understanding

Before diving into databases, patent searchers must develop deep domain knowledge about your invention. This involves:

• Analyzing technical specifications and drawings
• Understanding the problem your invention solves
• Identifying key innovative features and improvements
• Recognizing potential variations and alternative implementations
• Determining the appropriate technical terminology

Phase 2: Comprehensive Searching

The search phase employs multiple strategies simultaneously across various databases. Professional searchers combine different approaches to ensure no relevant prior art escapes detection. This phase requires access to premium databases and expertise in crafting effective search queries that balance precision with recall.

Phase 3: Analysis and Reporting

Search results undergo rigorous screening and classification:

• Highly Relevant: References that disclose the same or substantially similar invention
• Related: Documents showing some overlapping features but with significant differences
• Distantly Related: References in the same technical field but with minimal feature overlap
• Non-Relevant: Documents that appear in search results but lack meaningful connection

The final deliverable is a structured report that presents all identified references with analysis of their relevance to your invention's patentability.

Critical Benefits of Patentability Searches

Risk Mitigation and Informed Decision-Making

What is patentability search value in practical terms? The search provides critical intelligence that enables:

• Avoiding Wasted Investment: Patent application costs can range from $10,000 to $50,000 or more when including attorney fees, filing fees, and prosecution expenses. A patentability search costing a fraction of this amount can prevent pursuing unpatentable inventions.
• Strategic Patent Drafting: Search results inform patent attorneys about the prior art landscape, enabling them to craft claims that maximize protection while avoiding existing disclosures. This strategic approach increases the likelihood of patent grant and strengthens the resulting patent's value.
• Competitive Intelligence: Beyond patentability assessment, the search reveals competitors' activities, technological trends, and potential collaboration or licensing opportunities in your field.
• Portfolio Development Guidance: For organizations building patent portfolios, patentability searches identify white spaces where innovation efforts can focus for maximum return on investment.

Challenges in Conducting Comprehensive Searches

Technical Complexity

Understanding what is patentability search complexity involves recognizing several challenges:

• Terminology Variations: The same concept may be described using vastly different terminology across different patents, industries, and time periods. Effective searching requires identifying all relevant synonyms, technical terms, and colloquial expressions.
• Classification Inconsistencies: Patent classification systems evolve over time, and documents may be incorrectly classified or span multiple categories, requiring searchers to cast wide nets while maintaining precision.
• Language Barriers: Valuable prior art exists in numerous languages. While machine translation has improved, nuanced technical content may require native language expertise for accurate assessment.
• Rapidly Evolving Technologies: In fast-moving fields like artificial intelligence, biotechnology, and electronics, the time lag between invention disclosure and patent publication means recent innovations might not appear in databases until months or years later.

The Judgment Factor

Determining whether prior art makes an invention obvious remains inherently subjective. What seems obvious to one technical expert may represent a significant leap to another. Professional patent searchers combine technical expertise with experience in patent law principles to make reasoned assessments.

Why Professional Expertise Matters

What is patentability search without professional expertise? While inventors can conduct preliminary searches, professional search services offer distinct advantages:

• Specialized Database Access: Premium databases like Orbit, Derwent Innovation, and STN provide more comprehensive coverage and advanced search capabilities than free resources
• Technical and Legal Expertise: Professional searchers possess both technical domain knowledge and understanding of patent law principles
• Systematic Methodology: Established search protocols ensure comprehensive coverage and minimize the risk of missing critical prior art
• Quality Assurance: Multiple reviewers and standardized analysis frameworks provide confidence in search results

Conclusion: The Foundation of Successful Patent Strategy

Understanding what is patentability search and implementing it as a standard practice represents sound business strategy for any organization pursuing patent protection. This relatively modest upfront investment provides invaluable intelligence that shapes patent filing decisions, optimizes R&D resource allocation, and ultimately increases the success rate of patent applications.

A thorough patentability search serves as the foundation for building strong patent portfolios, avoiding costly rejections, and developing innovations that truly advance the state of the art in your industry. Whether you're an individual inventor, startup, or established corporation, making informed decisions based on comprehensive prior art searches maximizes your return on innovation investments and strengthens your competitive position in the marketplace.

Ready to protect your innovation with confidence? Contact Effectual Services today for a comprehensive patentability search conducted by experienced patent professionals with access to global databases and deep technical expertise across all technology domains.

 

About Effectual Services

Effectual Services is an award-winning Intellectual Property (IP) management advisory & consulting firm offering IP intelligence to Fortune 500 companies, law firms, research institutes and universities, and venture capital firms/PE firms, globally. Through research & intelligence we help our clients in taking critical business decisions backed with credible data sources, which in turn helps them achieve their organisational goals, foster innovation and achieve milestones within timelines while optimising costs.

We are one of the largest IP & business intelligence providers, globally serving clients for over a decade now. Our multidisciplinary teams of subject matter experts have deep knowledge of best practices across industries, are adept with benchmarking quality standards and use a combination of human and machine intellect to deliver quality projects. Having a global footprint in over 5 countries helps us to bridge boundaries and work seamlessly across multiple time zones, thus living to the core of our philosophy - Innovation is global, so are we !!!

Follow Us: Linkedin, Twitter