Overlap Between Design Patents and Trade Dress in Patent and Trademark Litigation
Introduction
Designs and eye-catching aesthetics of a product in today’s competitive market are equally important as that of the functionality of the product. Both design patent and trade dress plays a significant role as both represents two distinct yet interconnected forms of Intellectual property and influence patent success by enhancing market distinction and by establishing brand identity.
Understanding Design Patents
Design patents protect the aesthetic or decorative aspects of a product, such as its appearance, shape, and configuration. These patents do not cover the functional features of a product. To qualify for a design patent, the design must be new, original, and non-obvious. Once granted, a design patent provides protection for a period of 15 years from the date of issuance.
Understanding Trade Dress Protection
Trade dress refers to the overall commercial look and feel of a product, its packaging, or a service that helps identify and distinguish its source in the marketplace. For trade dress to be protected, the design must be non-functional, inherently distinctive or have acquired distinctiveness, and must possess secondary meaning in the minds of consumers. Trade dress protection continues for as long as the design remains distinctive.
Overlap Between Design Patents and Trade Dress
- Both protect the appearance and aesthetic features of a product.
- A single design may qualify for both protections if legal criteria are met.
- Design patents can cover functional designs if they are new and non-obvious.
- Trade dress requires the design to be non-functional, distinctive, and have secondary meaning.
- Examples:
- The Coca-Cola bottle shape
- Christian Louboutin red soles
Factors affecting patent and trademark litigation outcome:
- Commercial Success
- Timing of Sales
- Jurisdiction Consideration
Conclusion
Design patents and trade dress are essential tools for safeguarding a product's distinctive design. But one must find out what is needed and how he want to safeguard his merchandise. Since overlap between trade dress and design patents might make legal processes more difficult, one must decide which is the optimum usage situation. Additionally, overlapping will lead to diminish the scope and extent of claims.
Solutions Driving Innovation & Intelligence
Enabling Fortune 500's, R&D Giants, Law firms, Universities, Research institutes & SME's Around The Globe Gather Intelligence That
Protects and Nurtures Innovation Through a Team of 250+ Techno Legal Professionals.