Introduction

A patent that discloses a method or a process in compliance with a specific standard set by any standard organization is known as a standard essential patent. These standards are technical specifications of a product or technologies. Patents related to technology, telecommunications, or manufacturing can be granted based upon existing industry standards. These standard essential patent make sure that an invention must comply in accordance with the standard.

Impact of Standard Changes on Patent Validity

• Changes in standards do not impact the patent’s filing date or legal validity.
• They can affect the patent’s qualification as a Standard Essential Patent (SEP).
• If a patent no longer aligns with the updated standard, its value and enforceability under FRAND may decrease.
• Such changes trigger reassessment of the patent’s relevance and essentiality.

Challenges with the Patent

• Altered Standards: Changes in industry standards can reduce a patent’s relevance or enforceability; in significant cases, the patent may become non-essential or unenforceable.
• Novelty & Non-Obviousness: If updated standards reflect known solutions (prior art), the patent may lose novelty or be deemed obvious, affecting its validity.
• Compliance Issues: To remain enforceable as an SEP, the patented technology must align with the latest standard; otherwise, it risks becoming invalid or unenforceable.

Strategic and Legal Aspects for considerations

• Litigation Risk: Updated standards during a lawsuit can be used to challenge a patent’s validity or relevance.
• Patent Strategy: Companies must reassess SEP relevance and adjust licensing or enforcement strategies when standards evolve.
• Regulatory Framework: Standards changes may prompt validity reassessment; if the patent lacks novelty under new conditions, it may become unenforceable.

Way Forward

While changes to industry standards do not directly affect a patent's legal validity, they can impact its relevance, enforceability, and status as a Standard Essential Patent (SEP). A patent may lose its essentiality or face challenges if new standards introduce prior art or render the invention non-compliant. To stay effective, SEP holders must continuously reassess their portfolios in light of evolving standards, ensuring their patents remain strategically and legally enforceable.

Follow Us: Linkedin, Twitter